The decision
For a US seller in eBay's most-categories rate with no Store, a plain $100 sale costs $14.00 in eBay fees and $9.95 in Etsy fees, per both marketplaces' fee pages re-read November 17, 2026 (our arithmetic). Etsy stays cheaper at $20 and $50 too. An order that came through an Offsite Ad at 15% costs $24.95 on Etsy, so eBay wins that order. By our arithmetic, if more than about 27% of your $100 Etsy orders come through Offsite Ads at 15%, or about 34% at 12%, eBay costs less on average. Pull your Offsite Ads share before you decide where a listing goes.
Get fee and policy changes before they hit your margin
The free Daily Marketplace Brief flags fee and policy changes across Amazon, Walmart, TikTok Shop, eBay and Etsy, with the source document.
The short answer
eBay's selling fees page, re-read November 17, 2026, lists 13.6% "on total amount of the sale up to $7,500 calculated per item" for most categories, plus a per-order fee of $0.30 for orders of $10.00 or less and $0.40 above. The same page says you "don't have to worry about third-party payment processing fees," so that is the whole fee on a plain sale. Etsy's fees and taxes help page lists a 6.5% transaction fee and a $0.20 listing fee, and its payment processing help page lists 3% + 0.25 USD for a bank account in the United States, both re-read the same day.
Put the same item on both and Etsy keeps less at every price we tested. The table assumes a US seller, a US bank account, no eBay Store, eBay's most-categories rate, one item per order, no buyer-paid shipping, no sales tax and no ads. It is our arithmetic, rounded to the cent, and it matches the most-categories rows on our eBay $20 sale page, eBay $100 sale page, Etsy $20 sale page and Etsy $100 sale page.
| Item price | eBay fees (13.6% + per-order fee) | Etsy fees (6.5% + 3% + $0.25 + $0.20) | Etsy saves you | Etsy, Offsite Ads order at 15% | Etsy, Offsite Ads order at 12% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $20 | $3.12 (15.6%) | $2.35 (11.75%) | $0.77 | $5.35 | $4.75 |
| $50 | $7.20 (14.4%) | $5.20 (10.4%) | $2.00 | $12.70 | $11.20 |
| $100 | $14.00 (14.0%) | $9.95 (9.95%) | $4.05 | $24.95 | $21.95 |
What changed: eBay's most-categories rate is 13.6%, and Etsy's rates have not moved
Our fee change log recorded on October 16, 2026 that most eBay non-Store final value fees in our tables moved from 13.25% to 13.6% when we re-checked eBay's page, and that Etsy was confirmed unchanged. The pages we re-read November 17, 2026 still show 13.6% plus $0.30 or $0.40 for eBay's most categories, and 6.5%, $0.20 and 3% + $0.25 for Etsy. A comparison built on the older 13.25% understates eBay by $0.35 on a $100 sale.
eBay's rate is not one number. The same eBay page lists 15.3% for Books & Magazines, Movies & TV (except Movie NFTs) and Music (except Vinyl Records and Music NFTs), 13.25% for Coins & Paper Money (except Bullion) and select collectibles categories, 6.7% for Guitars & Basses, and separate schedules for watches, jewelry and handbags. This piece uses the most-categories rate. Check the exact rate for your category on our eBay fee table or the Most Categories calculator before you compare. Etsy charges one transaction rate in every category.
Why it matters: tax, shipping, Offsite Ads and idle listings
eBay charges its percentage on sales tax. Its fee page defines the total amount of the sale as the item price, handling, "any shipping costs collected from the buyer (some exceptions apply), sales tax, and any other applicable fees." Its own worked example charges 13.6% of $424 on a $400 item, because the $424 "includes 6% sales tax." Etsy's fees page names shipping and gift wrap in its transaction-fee base and does not list sales tax there. Etsy's two pages word processing differently: the payment processing page says it is taken from the total "including its shipping fees, and any applicable sales tax," while the fees page says "sales tax if you charge tax on the listing." On a hypothetical $100 item with $8 of sales tax, eBay takes $15.09 and Etsy $10.19 if processing runs on the tax (our arithmetic, using the stricter processing-page wording), so the gap grows from $4.05 to $4.90.
Buyer-paid shipping widens the gap the same way. Both marketplaces charge their percentage on shipping you collect: on $4 of shipping, eBay takes $0.54 and Etsy $0.38 (our arithmetic). eBay's page lists exceptions: for example, if you offer 1-day or international shipping as well as a cheaper domestic option, the base is calculated on the cheapest domestic option you offer.
Offsite Ads are where the comparison flips. Etsy's fees page lists the Offsite Ads fee at 15% of the order total if you made less than $10,000 on Etsy in the past 365 days, 12% if you made at least $10,000, and never more than $100 for an order. Etsy's Offsite Ads help page is stricter and is the rule we use: the 15% rate and the right to opt out apply only if your shop "has always made less than $10,000 USD in any consecutive 365 day period." Once a shop has made $10,000 in any such period, it pays 12% and is "required to participate for the lifetime of your shop." The help page describes the fee base as "the amount you made from your sale before the advertising fee was applied"; our table applies the rate to the item price, as the fees page's "order total" wording does for an order with no shipping. Our Offsite Ads analysis covers the opt-out and pricing math.
Here is the break-even, by our arithmetic. At $100, Etsy saves $4.05 on a plain order and costs $10.95 more on a 15% Offsite Ads order. If 27% of your $100 orders come through Offsite Ads at 15%, the two marketplaces cost the same on average; above that, eBay is cheaper. The same line sits at 25.7% of orders at $20 and 26.7% at $50. At the 12% rate it is 32.1% at $20, 33.3% at $50 and 33.8% at $100. Above the $100 cap, the ad fee stops growing: on a single item in eBay's most-categories rate, a capped Offsite Ads order costs less on Etsy than on eBay from about $2,440.
Idle listings run the other way. eBay gives sellers without a Store up to 250 zero insertion fee listings a month, then charges $0.35 per listing, and its Good 'Til Cancelled listings renew monthly and count toward the allowance each time. Etsy charges $0.20 per listing, and a listing expires after 4 months unless it auto-renews for another $0.20. On a hypothetical 200 unsold fixed-price listings, eBay charges nothing and Etsy $40 every four months. On 400, Etsy charges $80 every four months and eBay $52.50 a month, or $210 over the same four months. The crossover is about 290 active listings (our arithmetic, no eBay Store, no excluded categories, Etsy auto-renew on). eBay's zero insertion fee page lists categories that do not qualify and the larger allowances that come with Store packages.
What to do this week
Five checks, each under an hour:
- Pull your Offsite Ads share. Etsy's Offsite Ads dashboard shows revenue, fees, clicks and ad traffic; compare its attributed revenue with your total Etsy revenue over the last 90 days. Below roughly a quarter at 15%, or a third at 12%, Etsy is the cheaper home for an item that sells on both, by the arithmetic above.
- Look up your eBay category rate before you compare. Books & Magazines, Movies & TV and Music (with exceptions) pay 15.3%, Guitars & Basses 6.7%, and most other categories 13.6%, per eBay's fee page. Use our eBay vs Etsy comparison for the category view.
- Add sales tax to your eBay fee model. eBay's base includes the tax the buyer pays, so a margin sheet that applies 13.6% to the item price alone understates eBay's cut on every taxed order.
- Count your active listings. Under about 290 unsold listings, eBay's free allowance makes idle stock cheaper to hold there. Above that, Etsy's $0.20 every four months is cheaper per listing than eBay's $0.35 a month.
- Price the shipping, not just the item. Both marketplaces charge on shipping you collect, at 13.6% on eBay and 9.5% on Etsy (6.5% transaction plus 3% processing). Use the fee comparison by item price to check other marketplaces at the same price points.
What we're watching next
Whether eBay moves its non-Store rate again. The 13.25% to 13.6% shift in our tables is the reason so many quick comparisons are off. We log every change we confirm on the fee change log and on the intelligence dashboard.
Whether Etsy's two pages converge on how processing treats sales tax. Until they do, check one taxed order in your Payment account and model whichever line you see.
A hypothesis we have not measured: Etsy's Offsite Ads help page lists Google, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest and Bing among its ad channels, so your Offsite Ads share may run higher during holiday shopping weeks than your 90-day average. Check it weekly through the holidays rather than once.
Our Intelligence Dossier told operators to "treat fees as a variable, seasonal cost, not a rate card" and to "re-run per-channel contribution margin quarterly with current fee tables." This comparison is that exercise for two channels. None of the dated calls on our forecast scorecard is an eBay or Etsy fee call, so we do not tie this piece to one.
Questions sellers ask
Answers checked against eBay's and Etsy's fee pages on November 17, 2026.
- Is Etsy or eBay cheaper for sellers in 2026?
- On a plain sale with no ads, Etsy: $9.95 vs $14.00 on a $100 item, $5.20 vs $7.20 at $50 and $2.35 vs $3.12 at $20, for a US seller in eBay's most-categories rate with no Store (our arithmetic from both fee pages). An Offsite Ads order reverses it.
- How much does eBay take from a $100 sale?
- $14.00 in most categories with no Store: 13.6% of $100 plus the $0.40 per-order fee, per eBay's fee page. If the buyer pays sales tax, eBay charges 13.6% on that too.
- How much does Etsy take from a $100 sale?
- $9.95 for a US seller with a US bank account and no Offsite Ad: $6.50 transaction fee, $3.25 processing and the $0.20 listing fee. See our Etsy fee table.
- Does eBay charge a payment processing fee on top?
- No. eBay's fee page says you "don't have to worry about third-party payment processing fees"; the final value fee plus the per-order fee covers it.
- When does an Offsite Ads order make Etsy more expensive than eBay?
- On every Offsite Ads order in our table. A $100 order costs $24.95 at 15% or $21.95 at 12%, against $14.00 on eBay. Across all your orders, eBay is cheaper on average once Offsite Ads drive more than about 27% of $100 orders at 15%, by our arithmetic.
How this was made
We re-read eBay's selling fees page and zero insertion fee page, and Etsy's fees and taxes, payment processing and Offsite Ads help pages on November 17, 2026, and compared the rates with our eBay fee table and Etsy fee table (both verified October 16, 2026). Every dollar figure is our arithmetic on hypothetical orders, rounded to the cent, for a US seller with a US bank account, no eBay Store, no promoted listings or Etsy Ads, standard eBay seller performance and domestic buyers. eBay's international fee, its seller currency conversion charge, Etsy's 2.5% currency conversion fee and shipping labels are not in the table.
Prepared through an automated research and editorial process with evidence checks. No individual human review of this revision is claimed.
Sources
Consulted November 17, 2026. Carrier and platform terms change; check the current official documents and your own contract before acting.
- eBay Help: Selling fees ↗
Most categories 13.6% up to $7,500 per item; per-order fee $0.30 at $10.00 or less, $0.40 above; total amount of the sale includes shipping collected and sales tax; no third-party processing fees; 250 zero insertion fee listings then $0.35; category rates. Re-read Nov 17, 2026.
- eBay Help: Zero insertion fee listings ↗
Up to 250 listings a month with no Store package; larger allowances by Store package; categories that do not qualify. Re-read Nov 17, 2026.
- Etsy Help: What are the fees and taxes for selling on Etsy? ↗
$0.20 listing fee, 4-month expiry and auto-renew; 6.5% transaction fee on the order including shipping and gift wrap; Offsite Ads 15% or 12%, never more than $100 per order; 2.5% currency conversion. Re-read Nov 17, 2026.
- Etsy Help: What are payment processing fees for selling on Etsy? ↗
United States bank account: 3% + 0.25 USD, taken from the total sale price including shipping and any applicable sales tax. Re-read Nov 17, 2026.
- Etsy Help: How Etsy's Offsite Ads work ↗
15% and opt-out only if a shop has always made less than $10,000 in any consecutive 365-day period; 12% and lifetime participation after that; $100 per-order cap; ad channels. Re-read Nov 17, 2026.
- MarketplaceBeta: eBay vs Etsy fee comparison
Category-level comparison from our fee tables.
- MarketplaceBeta: eBay fees (verified Oct 16, 2026)
Basic non-Store rates by category; $0.30 / $0.40 per-order fee.
- MarketplaceBeta: Etsy fees (verified Oct 16, 2026)
6.5% transaction fee, $0.20 listing fee, 3% + $0.25 US processing.
- MarketplaceBeta: Fee change log
Oct 16, 2026: most eBay non-Store final value fees in our tables moved from 13.25% to 13.6%; Etsy confirmed unchanged.
- MarketplaceBeta: Etsy Offsite Ads fees 2026
Who can opt out, and pricing for the ad fee.
- MarketplaceBeta Intelligence Dossier, Edition 1 (Oct 14, 2026)
"Treat fees as a variable, seasonal cost, not a rate card"; re-run per-channel contribution margin quarterly.
- MarketplaceBeta forecast scorecard
No eBay or Etsy fee forecast; not tied to a forecast.
- MarketplaceBeta Intelligence hub
Operator analysis index.